Skip to content

Saturday Read: November 21 - Thanksgiving's Complex History

The traditional Thanksgiving story tells of Pilgrims and Wampanoag Indians sharing a harvest feast in 1621, celebrating cooperation and abundance. But the actual history is far more complex and troubling. Understanding this complexity doesn't require abandoning Thanksgiving—but it does require honesty about what we're celebrating and what we're choosing to ignore.

The Pilgrims arrived in Plymouth in December 1620 after a grueling voyage aboard the Mayflower. They landed in winter with inadequate supplies and no shelter. By spring, half of them were dead from exposure, scurvy, and disease. Those who survived did so partly because they settled on land recently cleared by the Patuxet people—who had been wiped out by European diseases several years earlier. The Pilgrims essentially occupied a plague-emptied village.

Squanto, the Patuxet man who taught Pilgrims to plant corn and fish, spoke English because he'd been kidnapped by English traders, sold into slavery in Spain, escaped to England, and finally returned to his homeland only to find his entire people dead from disease. His help to the Pilgrims was remarkable given what Europeans had done to him and his people.

The 1621 harvest celebration wasn't called "Thanksgiving" at the time. It was a three-day feast following English harvest festival traditions. The Wampanoag leader Massasoit attended with ninety men—far outnumbering the roughly fifty surviving Pilgrims. This wasn't a quaint dinner but a political event cementing an alliance between two groups who needed each other for survival.

Within decades, relationships between colonists and Native Americans deteriorated catastrophically. King Philip's War (1675-1678) killed thousands and devastated New England. Colonists sold captured Native Americans into slavery. Entire tribes were displaced or destroyed. The Thanksgiving story of harmony became tragic irony as the very people who helped Pilgrims survive were killed, enslaved, or driven from their lands.

On November 21, 1620—exactly one year before the first Thanksgiving—the Mayflower was still at sea, fighting storms and running low on supplies. The passengers had no idea they'd reach land within days or that half would die within months. They couldn't imagine that their settlement would become a nation or that their feast would become a national holiday. They simply endured, hoping to survive.

Modern Thanksgiving emerged much later. Sarah Josepha Hale campaigned for decades to establish a national Thanksgiving holiday. Abraham Lincoln finally proclaimed it in 1863—in the middle of the Civil War, when the nation was tearing itself apart. Lincoln called for thanksgiving not because circumstances were good but because God's faithfulness continued despite catastrophic suffering.

This complexity is important. Thanksgiving can't ignore the Native American perspective—that this holiday celebrates colonization that destroyed their peoples. Many Native Americans observe Thanksgiving as a National Day of Mourning, remembering ancestors who died from disease, warfare, and displacement following European arrival.

Yet gratitude remains biblically essential. Paul commanded: "Give thanks in all circumstances; for this is God's will for you in Christ Jesus" (1 Thessalonians 5:18). Notice: give thanks in all circumstances, not for all circumstances. You don't thank God for suffering, injustice, or evil. You thank God despite these—for his presence, his faithfulness, his sustaining grace.

Lincoln understood this. His Thanksgiving proclamation acknowledged "the lamentable civil strife in which we are unavoidably engaged" while calling the nation to remember "the ever watchful providence of Almighty God." He didn't pretend the war wasn't devastating. He called for gratitude amid devastation because God's faithfulness continued.

So how do you observe Thanksgiving honestly? First, acknowledge the complex history. The holiday emerged from events that brought suffering to Native Americans. You can be grateful for blessings while lamenting injustice. Second, practice thanksgiving that's honest about difficulty. God's faithfulness doesn't require pretending everything is fine. Third, use the day to actually thank God—not vaguely but specifically.

What are you genuinely grateful for? Name it. Not what you think you should be grateful for but what you actually appreciate. Food on your table. People you love. Health you have. Work that provides. Shelter that protects. These are gifts even when life is hard. Thanking God for what you have doesn't deny what you lack. It acknowledges that you have anything at all only because of his grace.

The Pilgrims who survived that first winter had lost half their community. Yet they celebrated harvest. They'd buried children, spouses, friends—yet they gave thanks. This wasn't denial. It was choosing gratitude amid grief, acknowledging provision despite loss, recognizing that God's faithfulness continued even when half of them died.

Twenty-one days into November, with Thanksgiving approaching, what genuine gratitude can you offer? Not performative gratitude that ignores pain but honest gratitude that thanks God for real blessings despite real difficulties. That's biblical thanksgiving—giving thanks in all circumstances because God's faithfulness endures.

Your lunchtime bible study will be here after your difficult morning.